Communist Manifesto | US “analog” | Crucial difference |
---|---|---|
Abolition of private property | Property tax | Paying up to 4.2% of your house value is not quite the same as having the commissars take it |
Heavy progressive income tax | The IRS | I’m pretty sure the Communists wanted the taxes to be much higher, so high private business wouldn’t be economically feasible. |
Abolition of all rights of inheritance | Inheritance tax | The difference between 100% and 40%. |
Confiscation of all property of emigrants and rebels | Regulations requiring disclosure of foreign accounts | Difference between telling the government about something and having that something taken away |
Central bank | Federal reserve | They got this one right. The Bank of England is a lot older, showing the idea isn’t uniquely Communist but it wasn’t nationalized until after WWII. |
Government control of communication and transportation | FCC and other regulators | Does the author wish to state it is dangerous to post memes critical of the government, as it would be under Communism? |
Government ownership of factories and agriculture | OSHA and one other logo I couldn’t read | OSHA doesn’t own productive enterprises |
Government control of labor | OSHA and Dept. of Labor | “Control” doesn’t mean a bit of regulation. It means for the government to decide what labor people will engage in. Very different from being told you cannot lock the factory door. |
Corporate farms, regional planning | Monstanto | A private corporation that doesn’t actually run the farms | Government control of education | Dept. of Education | Government control of publicly-funded education is a given (although it is mostly at lower levels than the federal). But private and home schooling is perfectly legal, IIRC |
h/t Randy Ship